中文

News

Response to Negative Claims about MEMS and Piezoelectric Acceleration Sensors

Zhongke Instruments · News2026-01-12 10:48:13

Home/News/Response to Negative Claims about MEMS and Piezoelectric Acceleration Sensors
Content

We recently learned that a competitor has been widely claiming to our customers that piezoelectric acceleration sensors andMEMSsensors are not suitable for blasting vibration measurement. To dispel customer concerns, we provide a detailed technical response to this situation.

MEMSThe measurement and control technology of MEMS sensors and piezoelectric acceleration sensors has developed rapidly in recent years and is widely used in highly reliable fields such as aerospace and fault diagnosis of large valuable machinery. At national metrology institutes verifying vibration monitoring instruments, piezoelectric acceleration sensors are integrated and then used to verify magnetoelectric sensors. Therefore, denying these two sensor types based solely on data comparison between magnetoelectric and chip sensors is extremely one-sided and irresponsible. Of course, this also reflects the anxiety of some competitors whose instrument R&D lags far behind. The technical issues raised by the competitor are answered one by one below.

1、On Integration Error

   MEMSChip acceleration sensors and piezoelectric acceleration sensors both output acceleration signals. Due to the existence of gravitational acceleration,Zaxis, or the sensor not being vertically installed, theX,Yaxis has a fixed DC component directly reflecting the magnitude of gravitational acceleration. If the gravitational acceleration is not completely removed from the signal before integration, the integrated velocity will show a monotonically increasing or decreasing velocity signal, leading to data errors. The competitor's solution of filtering gravitational acceleration with an analog high-pass filter certainly has serious technical defects:specifically, the parameter dispersion of electronic components, the input offset of operational amplifiers, and the temperature and humidity drift of components all cause uncontrollable DC offset in the circuit, so the gravitational acceleration cannot be completely separated - hence their product fails to pass. ZKCK uses a real-time digital filter built into the instrument, performing high-precision real-time filtering with a high-performance processor. Digital filters have no parameter consistency or environmental drift issues, ensuring very reliable removal of the gravitational acceleration DC component and thus reliable integration of acceleration.In actual testing, our instruments have undergone rigorous testing in high/low temperature and high humidity environments, and can measure acceleration and velocity stably and reliably in all of them.

2、On False Data

   MEMSChip and piezoelectric acceleration sensors have excellent low-frequency characteristics and can directly measure the constant gravitational acceleration. Therefore, when a sensor is not reliably fixed and encounters strong vibration, sensor displacement and tilt changes may occur. Due to the excellent low-frequency characteristics, the gravity component has a certain recovery time after passing through the digital high-pass filter during displacement - during this period larger integrated velocity data output does indeed appear.But this larger velocity data is not false or wrong - it is a signal that magnetoelectric velocity sensors simply cannot measure. A magnetoelectric sensor generates an electrical signal only through the relative motion between the spring-mass and the housing; only when the sensor as a whole has a certain acceleration can it transfer force to the spring mass and cause spring deformation,so a magnetoelectric sensor is equivalent to a second-order high-pass filter with a relatively high cut-off frequency - it cannot measure the very low-frequency acceleration and velocity signals at that moment. A simple everyday example illustrates this: many thrifty people turn the tap very small to a drip, at which point a mechanical water meter does not register, giving free tap water. With a very high-precision flow meter, the monthly water usage measured would differ greatly from the mechanical meter. From another perspective, when a sensor is displaced - e.g. at the instant it leaves the ground - the sensor is like a free-falling body no longer moving with the ground, and the signal measured at that moment has no reference value.

3、On High-Frequency Filtering

The "high-frequency mechanical filtering" mentioned in their document reflects a blind spot in the competitor's fundamental knowledge of vibration signal measurement - hard to believe it comes from a professional vibration measurement company. The so-called mechanical high-frequency filtering is actually the analog integration of acceleration by the spring mass due to inertia. We know the integrated signal output contains a1/wcoefficient term,wwhere omega is the angular frequency of the signal. Any integration operation produces a coefficient term of the reciprocal of the signal angular frequency: for acceleration signals of the same amplitude, the higher the frequency, the lower the output amplitude - this is their so-called mechanical high-frequency filtering.ZKCK instruments use a high-precision digital integration algorithm; the amplitude-frequency characteristics of digital integration are identical to those of analog integration- using this as a reason to attack ZKCK products is untenable and extremely ignorant.

Of course, we do not deny magnetoelectric sensors - they still have considerable advantages over chip and piezoelectric sensors in some aspects,and magnetoelectric sensors remain one of ZKCK's flagship sensor types- we make appropriate recommendations based on customers' actual application needs.The greatest advantage of magnetoelectric sensors is their extremely highsignal-to-noiseratio. Since magnetoelectric sensors directly output velocity signals, there is no integration of low-frequency noise in the integration stage, hence the extremely high SNR. Through built-in digital signal processing, ZKCK vibration instruments extend the measurement sensitivity of magnetoelectric sensor vibration signals tosub-micrometer per/second level,, far exceeding the SNR of peer instruments,therefore strongly recommended for micro-seismic application scenarios.. In addition, addressing the poor low-frequency response of magnetoelectric sensors, we specially launched thedigital low-frequency module, i.e. built-in digital low-frequency signal processing in the instrument, using digital integration, digital low-pass and digital high-pass filters to extend the amplitude-frequency characteristics of magnetoelectric sensors to low frequencies down tolow-frequency extension to1Hz. In fact, we have actually tested the performance of some competitors' sensors skilled at confusing the public: their claimed frequency response is1Hz-1KHz, while measured data shows their sensors only reach10Hz-300Hz。

Whether magnetoelectric sensors, acceleration sensors or various data loggers, ZKCK takes making quality products as its mission, winning customer recognition with strength and performance.