Possible causes of large errors in comparative testing of multiple blasting vibration meters:
1. The verification regulation allows an error range of ±10%; stacked between two units, the error can reach 20%;
2. Are the rigid connections of the compared sensors standard and consistent?
Generally, the better the rigid connection between the sensor and the measured point, the smaller the error;
3. The compared sensors are not on the same monitoring point, or the medium at the point is non-uniform;
The same location is not the same as the same particle: for the same vibration source, waveforms of the same frequency reaching different particles have different amplitudes (due to the inherent complexity of geological structure, the density between different particles at the same location may differ, causing the vibration wave to be weakened or strengthened during propagation, hence the difference) - especially obvious at high frequencies and short wavelengths. This is wave interference, with waveform superposition and cancellation. In reinforcement zones, particle amplitudes superpose and vibration strengthens; in weakening zones, amplitudes cancel and vibration weakens. Therefore the amplitude and waveform of data collected at the same location may differ.
4. The source signal frequency exceeds the sensor frequency response range (5-500 Hz);
5. Different sampling rate settings, or sensor sensitivity not set accurately;
6. Quality problems of the test system itself:
Insufficient accuracy of the vibration meter itself: caused by purchase from unofficial manufacturers, non-standard operation, harsh environment, improper protection, severe aging, disrepair, etc.;
Copper rust on the shield wire at signal cable joints can bias the data - common in coastal areas.
Solutions
1. In comparative testing, always ensure rigid connection between the compared sensors and the measured points;
2. Install the compared sensors on the same point, or swap instruments/sensors between different points for repeated comparison, to analyze whether it is a test-method problem or an instrument-accuracy problem;
3. Choose points with uniform geology or material as comparison test points;
4. Data beyond the sensor frequency response range (5-500 Hz) should not be used as comparison reference data;
5. Set the parameters of all compared instruments identically during comparative testing;
6. Send theBlasting Vibration Meterand corresponding sensors to an authoritative metrology institution for verification to obtain an authoritative conclusion;
Per the national verification regulation JJG 676-2000 "Working Vibration Meters", instrument accuracy should be measured with a professional vibration table and standard sensors - so results from informal test methods are for reference only.
7. If all instrument qualifications are fine, negotiate based on data analysis. Data reflects objective facts and has no absolute values - all are valid records of blasting vibration.
