中文

News

Vibration Safety Analysis of Rescue Passage Construction Blasting on Existing High-Speed Railway Tunnels

Zhongke Instruments · News2018-08-07 09:27:15

Home/News/Vibration Safety Analysis of Rescue Passage Construction Blasting on Existing High-Speed Railway Tunnels
Content

Abstract: To ensure the safety of the lining structure of the built Jindingshan high-speed railway tunnel, it is necessary to carry out blasting vibration monitoring on it during the blasting construction of the rescue passage.

The TC-4850N wireless network blasting vibrometer was used for monitoring. The monitoring results show that: the lining structure cross-section on the blast-facing side of the existing tunnel has the largest vibration; regression analysis of the monitoring data based on the least squares method obtained the parameters of the Sadovsky empirical attenuation formula for blasting vibration; based on the formula parameters, blasting vibration control measures were proposed for subsequent blasting, so that when the vibration velocity exceeds the safety threshold, blasting parameters are adjusted in time, achieving good results. Keywords: high-speed railway tunnel; vibration monitoring; blasting vibration; Sadovsky formula CLC number: U458

Document code: A

DOI :10.13238/j.issn.1004-2954.2016.03.021

Analysis of Vibration Impact Caused by Relief Channel Blasting on Existing High-speed Railway Tunnel

XIA Yi-ming 1,ZHENG Ming-xin 1,HU Guo-ping 1,LIU Jia-hua 1

(1.Institute of Bridge &Road &Geotechnical Engineering ,East China Jiaotong University ,Nanchang 330013,China )

Abstract :To ensure the safety of the lining structure of the existing Jin Shan Ding high-speed railway tunnel ,it is necessary to monitor blasting operation with TC-4850N wireless blasting monitoring system.The results show that the lining structure section on the blasting side of the existing tunnel vibrates the most.The blasting vibration Sodev's empirical attenuation formula parameters are obtained based on the least squares regression analysis of the monitoring data.And blasting vibration control measures for subsequent blasting operations are proposed in the light of formula parameters so that blasting parameters are adjusted timely once the vibration velocity exceeds the allowable limit.

Key words :High-speed railway tunnel ;vibration monitoring ;Blasting vibration ;Sodev's empirical formula of attenuation

In recent years, with the rapid development of high-speed railway construction in China, blasting technology plays an increasingly important role in the construction of railway tunnel projects.

At present, domestic tunnel blasting excavation mostly adopts the drill and blast method [1].

Some domestic scholars have done much research on tunnel blasting vibration monitoring; Cai

Dong et al. [2]

carried out blasting vibration monitoring on the Yeshanhe Tunnel and analyzed the influence of tunnel blasting vibration on the adjacent hydropower station; Song Fu [3]

carried out blasting vibration monitoring on the Aobaogou Tunnel,

and analyzed the influence of tunnel blasting vibration on adjacent existing buildings; Liu Yushan et al. [4]

carried out blasting vibration monitoring on the Daxuanling Tunnel and analyzed the influence of tunnel blasting vibration on the small clear-distance tunnel under construction. At present, there are many vibration safety analyses for sites adjacent to large hydropower stations, adjacent to existing buildings,

and adjacent to tunnels under construction, but few vibration safety analyses for sites adjacent to built high-speed railway tunnels. Blasting excavation will produce blasting seismic waves, and the vibration generated by seismic waves will have

adverse effects on the existing adjacent high-speed railway tunnel,

mainly manifested in that blasting vibration will cause uneven deformation of the high-speed railway tunnel lining structure, which may in turn

cause cracks in the lining structure [5].

Therefore, during tunnel blasting excavation, the monitoring and research of blasting vibration must be strengthened, and effective measures must be taken to control the intensity of blasting vibration.

Taking the blasting construction of the Jindingshan Tunnel rescue passage as the research object, the vibration generated by tunnel blasting excavation was monitored; according to the monitored data and blasting vibration response, the blasting design parameters of the new tunnel construction were adjusted and optimized in time to protect the existing adjacent built high-speed railway tunnel from damage.

1

Project overview

As the disaster prevention and evacuation

works of the Jindingshan Tunnel,

the rescue passage of the Jindingshan Tunnel is designed as a parallel adit-type tunnel, located on the right side of the Jindingshan Tunnel portal parallel to the main tunnel, connecting with the existing comprehensive chamber on the right side of the portal section line (orthogonal chainage DK355+224), with a clear distance of about 30 m from the main tunnel; the relative position of the rescue passage and the main tunnel is shown in Figure 1. The parallel adit has a total length of 597 m, with a cross-section clearance size of 5 m (width) x 6 m (height). The parallel adit is located in a denuded medium-low mountain area, with crisscrossing valleys, developed vegetation and natural slopes of 30-55 degrees. The strata of the site area are mainly Yanshanian granite and silty slate of the Mesoproterozoic Banqiao Formation. The surrounding rock of the rescue passage tunnel is divided into 3 engineering geological sections, namely Class II, IV and V rocks,

Tunnel Surrounding Rock Classification

Corresponding chainage section length/m

Rock Mass Type

Surrounding Rock Grade

XDK0+000

XDX0+478, 478 m: granite, weakly weathered, hard rock, relatively intact rock mass, II; XDK0+478 to XDX0+503, 25 m: silty slate, weakly weathered, hard rock, fractured rock mass, IV; XDK0+503 to XDX0+597:

94

granite, strongly weathered, hard rock,

fractured rock mass, V

The main tunnel of the Jindingshan Tunnel adopts a composite lining structure; within 150 m of the portal section, the lining adopts a C35 concrete combined with steel mesh lining structure, with a secondary lining thickness of 40-50 cm and concrete strength of 35 MPa. Beyond 150 m of the portal section, a C30 plain concrete lining structure is adopted, with a secondary lining thickness of 35-40 cm. The rescue passage construction adopts manual blasting operations. 2

Tunnel Blasting Vibration Monitoring 2.1

Monitoring Instruments and Methods

This tunnel blasting vibration monitoring intends to adopt a vibration monitoring system consisting of the TC-4850N wireless network blasting vibrometer,

the Blasting vibration analysis software, computer, printer, etc. The vibration monitoring and acquisition system is shown in Figure 2. During on-site monitoring, three directional velocity sensors - vertical, tangential and radial - are arranged at the same measuring point; the sensors are fixed with 502 glue at the parts to be monitored, and then the sensors are connected to the blasting vibrometer.

When blasting vibration is transmitted to the measuring point, the blasting vibration recorder automatically records the signal, which is then uploaded via the wireless network to a dedicated server on the Internet.

After blasting, the accompanying blasting vibration analysis software can be used to download the vibration signals to the computer via the network for analysis and processing.


2.2 Layout of Measuring Points

The sensors are arranged on the springing of the blast-facing side of the existing railway tunnel. In order to analyze the distribution of the vibration field and understand the influence of blasting vibration on the existing tunnel, 3 cross-section measuring points are arranged within the 40-50 m range where the blast source directly faces the existing tunnel; each measuring point includes 3 velocity sensors: the vertical ground direction (vertical), the horizontal radial direction (with its long axis pointing to the blast source), and the horizontal tangential direction (perpendicular to the radial); each observation point simultaneously performs vertical and two horizontal direction observations.

The testing work and the tunnel blasting excavation operations are carried out simultaneously; according to the layout of the measuring points,

the measuring points and the blast source go through a process from near to far.

Blasting Vibration Monitoring Analysis 3.1

Typical Blasting Vibration Waveform Characteristics

The parallel adit tunnel construction adopts manual blasting operations, with blasting initiated in 7 segments; segments 1 and 2 are cut hole blasting, segments 3 to 5 are helper hole blasting, segment 6 is floor hole blasting, and segment 7 is perimeter hole blasting. To reduce the impact of blasting on the adjacent tunnel, smooth blasting was adopted in construction; according to the characteristics of the surrounding rock and the cross-section size, the cut holes use wedge cuts initiated in two segments; helper holes should avoid joints and fissures with reasonably selected spacing; perimeter holes should be reasonably spaced and uniformly arranged along the excavation contour line.

The hole depths of both helper holes and perimeter holes are 1.8 m, with hole bottoms on the same vertical plane; the cut hole depth is 2.0 m. The single-hole charge quantities of helper holes and perimeter holes

are 0.9 kg and 0.36 kg respectively; the cut hole single-hole charge is 1.7-2.0 kg; the maximum single-segment initiation charge Q of tunnel smooth blasting is 20.4-24.6 kg.

At the typical monitoring point DK355+150 of the Jindingshan Tunnel, the vibration time-history curves of the particle in the vertical, horizontal radial and horizontal tangential directions are shown in Figure 5. As can be seen from Figure 5, the vibration time-history curve has 7 changes

corresponding to the 7-segment initiation sequence; the maximum vibration velocity appears in segment 2, that is, the maximum vibration velocity corresponds to the cut hole blasting moment, so the maximum charge of the cut holes should be controlled. Due to the reasonable delay blasting time adopted, the vibration waveforms of each segment are independent, with no obvious vibration superposition effect.

3.2

Analysis of Blasting Vibration Velocity Variation Characteristics

3.2.1 Discussion on monitoring control standards

The physical quantities of vibration are generally expressed by particle vibration velocity, acceleration, displacement and vibration frequency [6]. Which physical quantities of vibration are used as criteria for measuring the intensity of blasting vibration effects have different emphases in different engineering practices. At home and abroad, the ground particle vibration velocity is mostly adopted as the criterion for measuring blasting intensity. Some scholars have also studied that the dominant vibration frequency of blasting vibration is also a criterion for measuring blasting vibration intensity [7-8], an important factor that cannot be ignored. According to China's Safety

Regulations for Blasting [9] (GB 6722-2011), the dominant vibration frequency is also included in consideration.

Combining the actual situation of this project with current research results and engineering experience, according to the provisions of the Safety Regulations for Blasting (GB 6722-2011), the safety vibration velocity standard for railway traffic tunnels is controlled at 10 cm/s < V < 20 cm/s. Considering that the Jindingshan high-speed railway tunnel is in trial operation, excessive blasting vibration may cause uneven deformation of the roadbed of the trial-operating high-speed railway line and damage to auxiliary facilities such as line fire protection, power supply lighting and communication. To avoid the above serious consequences affecting the traffic safety of the trial-operating high-speed railway, and to ensure the safety of the tunnel lining structure, it is stipulated that the permissible blasting vibration velocity for existing operational railway tunnels should not exceed 5 cm/s. 3.2.2 Analysis of vibration velocity variation trend

13 blasting monitoring sessions were carried out at DK355+150, and the Blasting vibration analysis software was used to synthesize the waveforms of the 3 vibration directions, obtaining the vector vibration velocity peaks of the new waveform. The specific monitoring data are shown in Table 2, showing the trend of particle vibration velocity peaks at the measuring point.


Tunnel blasting vibration monitoring data - Test No., R/m, Q/kg, Radial

Tangential, Vertical, Vector Synthesis

Vibration velocity/(cm/s), Dominant frequency/Hz, Vibration velocity/(cm/s), Dominant frequency/Hz, Vibration velocity/(cm/s), Dominant frequency/Hz, Vibration velocity/(cm/s)

1

32.624.6 4.84444.41 2.49101.32 5.52320.00 5.26233.224.6 4.66470.67 2.26156.91 5.29333.36 5.07334.121.4 3.97400.00 2.33121.21 4.29285.71 4.12434.921.4 3.69363.65 2.06170.26 4.25235.36 3.92535.821.4 3.58173.92 2.31166.71 4.12235.30 3.83636.623.2 4.62381.26 3.7684.23 4.52296.38 4.58737.323.2 4.44277.83 2.2367.66 4.31277.82 4.39838.120.4 3.69357.14 2.03138.98 3.96192.37 3.79939.020.4 3.52125.00 1.9556.84 3.8096.28 3.711041.120.4 3.33250.00 1.27100.00 3.64192.35 3.541142.320.4 3.05210.56 1.6894.14 3.48216.23 3.261243.620.4 2.86227.330.81312.50 3.22178.62 3.0513

44.7

20.4

2.58470.63

1.06119.42

3.08258.17

2.83

Note: R is the horizontal distance between the blast center and the measuring point; Q is the maximum single-segment initiation charge corresponding to the vibration velocity V.

From Table 2 and Figure 6, it can be seen that:

(1) At the measuring point cross-section DK355+150, except for the first vertical vibration velocity of 5.52 cm/s and the second vertical vibration velocity of 5.29 cm/s, the peak particle vibration velocities of other tests are all within the safety standard of 5 cm/s. This may be because the horizontal distance between the measuring point and the blast center is short,

and the maximum single-segment initiation charge is too large; while the rescue passage is a parallel adit

type tunnel; at each blasting, the Jindingshan Tunnel must have a cross-section directly facing the blast center (this cross-section is the most dangerous cross-section), and the minimum horizontal distance is the horizontal distance between the measuring point and the blast center of about 32.6 m. Therefore, the blasting peak particle vibration velocity can only be controlled by adjusting the maximum single-segment initiation charge or other measures - peak vibration velocity variation trend.

(2) The peak vibration velocities of the measuring point in the vertical and radial directions are significantly greater than the tangential; the vertical is smaller than the radial only in the 6th and 7th tests, and greater than the radial in other tests. It can be seen that the peak particle vibration velocity toward the free face is significantly greater than other directions; the vector-synthesized peak vibration velocity is between the vertical and radial, possibly because the vibration velocity peaks of the 3 directions at the same measuring point are not reached simultaneously, with a certain time difference. Therefore, on the blast-facing surface, the vertical is the direction most prone to damage, that is, the most dangerous direction, followed by the radial; the tangential peak vibration velocity is significantly smaller than other directions. In future similar projects, only the vertical and radial vibration velocities can be monitored to simplify blasting vibration monitoring.

(3) With the maximum single-segment initiation charge unchanged, the particle vibration velocity peak V has an obvious correspondence with the blast center distance R; as blasting construction advances, the measuring points and the blast source go through a process from near to far, and the peak particle vibration velocity at the measuring point also shows a gradually attenuating trend as the blast center distance gradually increases.

(4) Except for a few points with dominant vibration frequencies below 100 Hz, the rest are all above 100 Hz; the three-directional dominant vibration frequencies of blasting vibration are mainly concentrated in 100-400 Hz, belonging to high-frequency vibration.

3.2.3 Regression analysis of the blasting vibration attenuation formula

After blasting, energy is released rapidly and propagates outward in the form of waves, causing particle vibration of the medium, but blasting vibration attenuates quickly. Based on existing research results, the Sadovsky empirical attenuation formula is generally used at home and abroad to perform regression analysis on blasting vibration data [10-12]:

V = K (Q^(1/3)/R)^α (1)

Where V is the particle vibration velocity generated by blasting, cm/s; R is the straight-line distance between the blast source and the measuring point, m; Q is the maximum single-segment initiation charge of blasting, kg; K is the coefficient related to geological conditions and surrounding rock characteristics; α is the blasting attenuation coefficient.

Taking the natural logarithm of both sides of Formula (1) gives:

ln V = ln K + α ln(Q^(1/3)/R) (2). Let ln V = y, ln(Q^(1/3)/R) = x, ln K = b, α = m; then Formula (2) is transformed into a unary linear regression formula.

y=mx+b(3)

Using Formulas (1) to (3) to perform least squares regression on the data in Table 1 gives the Sadovsky empirical attenuation formulas (Table 3).

Table 3 Sadovsky empirical attenuation formulas

Direction, Correlation coefficient: V vertical = 141.173 (Q^(1/3)/R)^1.360, 0.94; V radial = 162.39

(Q^(1/3)/R)^1.450, 0.82; V synthesis = 156.02

(Q^(1/3)/R)^1.420, 0.89

According to the obtained Sadovsky empirical attenuation formula, the maximum single-segment initiation charge can be estimated to ensure that the blasting vibration velocity peak of the high-speed railway tunnel lining structure is within the safety control standard.

Qmax=RminVmax()K3α

From the actual site engineering and safety control standards: Rmin =

32.6 m, Vmax = 5 cm/s; substituting into the formulas in Table 3 for calculation, obtaining the maximum single-segment initiation charge and taking the minimum value, gives Qmax = 21.5 kg.

4 Conclusion

According to the design requirements and the Safety Regulations for Blasting (GB 6722-2011), vibration monitoring and analysis were carried out on the blasting process of the Jindingshan Tunnel rescue passage; the following conclusions were obtained through analysis of the monitoring data.

(1) During tunnel blasting excavation, at the initial monitoring, the blast source directly faces the measuring point and is closest to it, producing the largest peak vibration velocity; as the distance between the blast source and the measuring point gets farther, the corresponding peak vibration velocity also gradually attenuates. With the maximum single-segment initiation charge unchanged, the particle vibration velocity peak V has an obvious correspondence with the blast center distance R.

(2) The three-directional dominant vibration frequencies of blasting vibration are mainly concentrated in 100-400 Hz, belonging to high-frequency vibration, much higher than the natural frequency of the existing Jindingshan high-speed railway tunnel lining structure, so resonant damage will not occur due to blasting.

(3) Based on least squares regression analysis of the monitoring data, the Sadovsky empirical attenuation formulas for the vertical and radial directions were obtained, and the maximum single-segment initiation charge under the safety control standard is 21.5 kg. In subsequent blasting construction, it is recommended to control the maximum single-segment initiation charge within 21.5 kg for better results.

References:

[1] Li Shucai, Liu Bin, Sun Huaifeng, et al. Current status and development trends of advanced geological prediction in tunnel construction [J].

Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering, 2014, 33(6): 1090-1113.

[2] Cai Dong, Wu Li, Liang Yu. Monitoring and analysis of blasting vibration in the Yeshanhe Tunnel [J]. Blasting,

2009,26(4):89-92.

[3] Song Fu. Blasting vibration monitoring and vibration reduction measures for the underpass works of the Aobaogou Tunnel [J].

Railway Engineering, 2013(2): 43-45.